A Telegraph Through a Hidden Tunnel in Time ✛ ✎ ✦

Original: "Quantum Entanglement without nonlocal causation in (3,2)-dimensional spacetime"
· Marco Pettini
arXiv:2311.17070 · 2023-11-26 · arXiv non-exclusive · independent analysis · 2 min
Quantum entanglement can be described as an exchange of information through a hidden extra time dimension — without superluminal signals and without abandoning causality.

Two couriers leave the same city in opposite directions. An hour later, each opens an envelope: one contains a slip marked “plus,” the other “minus.” How did they know who would get which? In the quantum world, such a pair is called entangled, and its particles behave exactly the same way: measuring one instantly determines the state of the other, even if they are kilometers apart.

Standard physics forbids superluminal signals, so the correlations of entangled particles are considered inexplicable in ordinary spacetime. The author of the new work proposes a toy model: the two couriers do not communicate directly, but both call a hidden dispatch center located in a second time dimension. The signal travels there at a finite speed, but for us, living in a single time, the conversation appears instantaneous.

Instead of hidden variables, a hypothetical subquantum field is introduced, which propagates in an extra time dimension at a finite speed. To describe the information-carrying pulse, the sine-Gordon equation is used: it describes stable waves, like solitary humps, that do not spread as they move.

The model reproduces the standard correlations for an entangled pair: if one particle collapses into the “plus” state, the other collapses into “minus.” The key prediction is the appearance of the same correlations between particles from different pairs, if their detectors are closer to each other than to their partners. This can be tested by measuring the parameter S in Bell's inequality: for independent particles it should be no more than 2, while the model allows up to 2√2 ≈ 2.828.

An experimental scheme is proposed: two independent sources of entangled photons, with Alice's and Eve's detectors placed close together, and Bob's and Tom's detectors far apart. If correlations violating Bell's inequality appear between Alice and Eve, this would indicate information exchange through the extra time dimension.

The work differs from neighboring approaches by using an extra time dimension instead of extra spatial dimensions or superluminal signals. This preserves causality while providing a “mechanism” for the correlations. If the experiment confirms the hypothesis, information would gain ontological status, as Wheeler suggested. If not, a new constraint would be established, limiting models with extra time dimensions.

For now, this is pure knowledge, with no applications in sight. But two couriers with envelopes are no longer just a trick: they are a possible trace of a hidden tunnel through which nature sends messages faster than we can notice.

Extra temporal dimensions are usually avoided because of the 'grandfather paradox': time travel could allow you to kill your ancestor. The author sidesteps this by assuming that only the subquantum field lives in two times, while particles remain in one.

Scientists
Abner ShimonyAlain AspectAnton ZeilingerArtur EkertDaniel GreenbergerJohn Clauser
Concepts
temporal entanglement quantum connections quantum correlation correlation nonlocality extra time dimensions bell test gravitational entanglement spooky action at a distance information spread bell states extra dimension toy model locality electronic correlations entangled photon pairs coupling bottleneck dimensionality instanton