Why Strong El Niño Events Strike Out of Nowhere ✎

Original: "Intrinsic unpredictability of strong El Niño events"
arXiv:1607.02645 · 2016-07-09 · arXiv non-exclusive · independent analysis · 1 min
The ocean is like a pendulum that can swing in two modes: strong and weak, and the switch between them is unpredictable.

Warm water in the Pacific Ocean sometimes shifts toward South America. This phenomenon is called El Niño, and it changes weather around the globe. Occasionally El Niño is very strong, while at other times it barely appears. Why this happens has long been a puzzle.

Scientists built a simple computer model of the ocean. It turns out that the model has two modes, much like a pendulum. In one mode, the pendulum swings high and regularly, corresponding to years with strong El Niño events. In the other mode, it jitters with small oscillations, and no strong events occur. The switch between modes is triggered by very small perturbations, such as seasonal changes.

In the model, an era without strong El Niño events could last more than two hundred years, and then a series of powerful events would suddenly begin.

This means that precisely predicting the strength of El Niño many years ahead is impossible. However, one can estimate probabilities, just like in weather forecasts: not "will it rain?" but "what is the chance of rain?" The Pacific pendulum swings on its own, and guessing its next big swing is beyond our reach.

In a 6000-year simulation of the model, an epoch without strong El Niño could last more than two centuries, then suddenly give way to a series of intense events, all without any external forcing other than a weak seasonal cycle.

\begin{cases} x' = \rho\delta(x^2 - ax) + x(x + y + c - c\tanh(x+z)) \\ y' = -\rho\delta(ay + x^2) \\ z' = \delta(k - z - \frac{x}{2}) \end{cases}
x is the sea surface temperature difference between the eastern and western equatorial Pacific, y is the western Pacific surface temperature relative to a nominal value, and z is the western thermocline depth. The parameters δ, ρ, c, k, a represent combinations of physical characteristics of the tropical Pacific.
Concepts
ENSO El Niño-Southern Oscillation El Niño La Niña spring predictability barrier Southern Oscillation Multivariate ENSO Index recharge oscillator model Jin-Timmermann model Westerly wind burst ERSST interannual variability Warm water volume equatorial wave propagation natural variability North Equatorial Countercurrent TAO/TRITON moorings relative ONI NOAA CPC seasonal cycle