Why Redundant Records Generate Work express

Original: "The Locality Gap: A Thermodynamic Law for Objective Facts"
· Maxim V. Churilov
arXiv:2608.05753v1 · 2026-08-06 · CC BY 4.0 · 1 min
Quantum Darwinism gains a thermodynamic meaning: redundant copies of information create an asymmetry that can be measured in joules.

In the quantum world, a fact becomes objective when its value is imprinted on many independent fragments of the environment, like a notice posted on hundreds of bulletin boards across the city. Each copy alone adds no new information, but it changes the rules of the game for anyone trying to erase that information.

The authors considered a cloud of records entropy and divided it into blocks that cannot be controlled jointly. They found that erasing information at a fixed temperature costs a local controller more work than a global one. The difference is exactly equal to the energy of thermal motion of particles multiplied by a measure of statistical dependence between blocks. This extra cost is called the thermodynamic charge of factuality.

If the source of the event is presented as a catalytic hint, the charge of factuality ranges from negative values (perfect secret sharing) to large positive ones (broadcast objectivity).

The magnitude of the charge depends on the access architecture. One person sees all the bulletin boards at once, while another sees only one. To erase a record, the second person must visit each board individually, and each extra step costs energy. Thus, redundancy of records becomes a measurable resource — work that can be calculated in joules. The study does not change quantum mechanics but points out the thermodynamic consequences of how access to information is structured.

The thermodynamic charge of factuality can take negative values: this corresponds to perfect secret sharing, where knowledge is distributed so that no single fragment reveals the whole picture.

\mathcal{F}_{\mathcal{P}}^{T}=k_{\mathrm{B}}T\left[\sum_{B\in\mathcal{P}}I(X{:}F_B)-I(X{:}F)\right]
Thermodynamic charge of factuality: the difference between the sum of mutual information of the source with each block and the mutual information with the whole cloud, multiplied by thermal energy.
Scientists
Ludwig BoltzmannRudolf ClausiusJacob BekensteinStephen HawkingJames Clerk MaxwellEdward Witten
Concepts
landauer limit Landauer's principle information processing information thermodynamics locality irreversibility randomness conservation law causality quantum law quantum corrections reversibility data nonlocality false vacuum waste heat thermodynamics proportionality redundancy zeroth law of thermodynamics