Climate Moves in Steps, Not a Steady Climb ✎

Original: "The Shifts Hypothesis - an alternative view of global climate change"
· P. V Belolipetsky
arXiv:1406.5805 · 2014-06-23 · arXiv non-exclusive · independent analysis · 2 min
From 1950 to 2013, global temperature didn't rise smoothly but jumped in two sharp steps, in 1987/1988 and 1997/1998.

A kitchen thermometer doesn't creep upward gradually when you turn on the stove: first it stays put for a while, then suddenly jumps a few degrees. According to researchers' calculations, global temperature behaved much the same way from 1950 to 2013.

First, the linear influence of El Niño was subtracted from the HadCRUT4 data to remove the ocean's natural "ripple." What remained is a step-like curve: three nearly flat segments (1950–1987, 1988–1997, 1998–2013) and two sharp rises between them.

During stable periods, temperature barely changed, even though greenhouse gases kept accumulating. But in 1987/1988 and 1997/1998, average temperature jumped so quickly that these jumps account for almost all the warming over the 63 years. Trend maps for the quiet years show only local patches, while maps of differences between periods look like global heating.

Such a pattern fits poorly with the "forcing–response" model, where temperature should smoothly follow the rise in carbon dioxide concentration. Instead, the data hint at a global thermostat: the system seems to hold to one "set point," then quickly switches to another. A simple regression with two factors (El Niño and climate regime) explains 78% of monthly and 87% of annual variability.

The thermostat hypothesis was discussed as early as 1991, when the New York Times wrote about possible climate self-regulation. A cloud-based mechanism was proposed by Ramanathan and Collins.

Now this idea has quantitative support. If climate indeed moves in steps, then forecasts based on smooth trends may be systematically wrong at transition points. The remaining questions are what exactly pushes the system from one step to another, and whether such jumps occurred in the past.

The idea of a climate thermostat was discussed as early as 1991, when the New York Times wrote about possible self-regulation of climate, and a cloud-based mechanism was proposed by Ramanathan and Collins.

Concepts
global warming seasonal forcing natural variability annual cycle greenhouse effect El Niño climate ENSO temperature anomaly heat flow Jin-Timmermann model El Niño-Southern Oscillation climate network Pacific decadal oscillation decadal variability regime shift heat carbon cycle UAH satellite record Allen's rule