Ocean Conveyor Belts Decide Whether It's El Niño or La Niña ✎

Original: "Current-Generating Mechanism for El Niño & La Niña, an Data Evidence from Integrated ESMD Method"
· Jin-Liang Wang
arXiv:1912.02100 · 2019-11-25 · arXiv non-exclusive · independent analysis · 3 min
The warm and cold phases of the climate cycle are triggered not by vertical oscillations but by horizontal currents that carry water to the right parts of the Pacific Ocean.

In the tropical Pacific, the ocean sometimes warms more than usual, sometimes cools. Fishermen off the coast of Peru noticed this centuries ago and named the warm phase El Niño, which means 'little boy,' because it arrived around Christmas. Today, these temperature swings affect weather across the planet: from droughts in Australia to downpours in California. But exactly how the ocean switches between warm and cold states remains unclear. Classical theories talk about waves that run along the equator and rock the layer with a sharp temperature gradient with depth. The new work offers a different view: horizontal currents that carry warm or cold water to the right regions play the leading roles.

Currents work like conveyor belts in a vast ocean factory. One belt carries warm water from west to east, another brings cold water from the south. If a belt speeds up, goods pile up at the end of the line: heat or cold.

To test this idea, the author decomposed data on sea surface temperature from 1950 to 2017 and current velocities from 1993 to 2016 into oscillations with different periods. The method, called ESMD, extracts individual modes from a messy signal and shows where and when they change. Then indices were built for four sensitive regions that correspond to pathways of warm water from the north and cold water from the south. Comparing these indices with temperature anomalies revealed which current triggers what.

It turned out that the central equatorial countercurrent (CECC) starts strengthening two to three months before a warm anomaly appears in the central Pacific. The northern equatorial countercurrent (NECC) leads warming in the eastern part by several months, sometimes up to two years. For the eastern type of El Niño, the Niño-B index proved decisive, reflecting the transport of warm water from the coast of Central America southward. For the central type, the Niño-A index, linked to a break in the northern countercurrent, plays the main role. For La Niña, the picture is different: the southern branch of the South Equatorial Current (SSEC) strengthens five to seven months before cooling and drags cold water from the southeastern ocean straight into the central equatorial zone.

The asymmetry between El Niño and La Niña is simple to explain: the sources of warm and cold water are in different places. Warm water comes from the north and west, cold water from the southeast. So both the conveyor belt routes and their speeds differ.

This work changes our understanding of how the climate cycle is born. Whereas scientists previously focused mainly on vertical processes, such as how the layer with a sharp temperature gradient rises and falls, the spotlight now is on horizontal currents. Current indices can serve as early indicators of events: a strengthening northern countercurrent warns of El Niño months ahead, and the southern branch of the South Equatorial Current warns of La Niña half a year in advance. For countries that depend on the whims of tropical weather, this is time to prepare: from water reserves to strengthening coastlines. The ocean's conveyor belts, it turns out, can be tracked in advance, and thus we can predict what goods they will deliver next time.

The name 'El Niño' originally referred to a warm current that appeared annually off the coasts of Peru and Ecuador during the weakening of the southeast trade winds, not to a temperature anomaly as such.

Concepts
North Equatorial Countercurrent ENSO recharge oscillator model La Niña Jin-Timmermann model El Niño-Southern Oscillation El Niño Multivariate ENSO Index Southern Oscillation ERSST NOAA CPC spring predictability barrier Indian Ocean capacitor effect Warm water volume equatorial wave propagation ocean current Bjerknes feedback TAO/TRITON moorings relative ONI Westerly wind burst