Black Holes in a Sink of Water ✎ express

Original: "Hawking radiation with dispersion: reconciling the Bogoliubov and tunneling approaches"
arXiv:2604.24861 · 2026-04-27 · arXiv non-exclusive · independent analysis · 2 min
An event horizon can emerge not only in space but also in an ordinary fluid, if waves in it move faster than sound.

Water flowing through a pipe can become a trap for sound. If the flow speed exceeds the speed of sound in water, then sound waves trying to go against the current can no longer escape: they are swept away, like light beyond a black hole's horizon. This is not just a metaphor: in such analog systems, particles akin to Hawking radiation are indeed born.

The authors considered a trickier case — when the speed of waves depends on their wavelength, and short waves can move faster than sound. It turns out that a horizon still emerges, but not where the flow speed matches the speed of sound, but deeper, where it catches up with the faster waves. Using an elegant mathematical trick, the S-matrix near the horizon, they calculated how many particles are born and compared the results with the tunneling method. Both approaches agreed: the spectrum turned out to be almost thermal, with a temperature set by the effective surface gravity of the new horizon.

Effective surface gravity is not a gravitational force but a measure of how quickly the flow speed increases as you approach the horizon. The steeper the increase, the hotter the radiation.

This means that Hawking radiation is not a quirk of strictly relativistic physics but a general property of media with horizons. Even if familiar laws change at extremely small distances, black holes will still 'shine.' And analog experiments with fluids or light in the lab gain a solid theoretical foundation.

A translator gets distracted by every rustle in the hall, and a one-hour meeting stretches into two. Likewise, adding fast short waves does not break the picture; it merely shifts the horizon and slightly changes the temperature.

In 1981, Bill Unruh showed that sound waves in a moving fluid behave like light in curved spacetime. Since then, physicists have tried to create a 'sonic black hole' in the lab to catch its analog of Hawking radiation.

In Stanislaw Lem's novel 'Fiasco,' astronauts use analog models to understand the properties of alien civilizations — much like physicists model black holes in fluids.

Scientists
Stephen HawkingJacob BekensteinWilliam UnruhFritz ZwickyKarl SchwarzschildSubrahmanyan Chandrasekhar
Concepts
Hawking radiation hawking radiation anomalies analogue black holes Bekenstein-Hawking entropy Hubble's law black hole superradiance Aharonov–Bohm effect apparent horizon quantum gravity analogues horizon area surface gravity Poiseuille's equation hawking radiation mechanism gravitational wave propagation analog black hole event horizon stability black hole evaporation dispersion relation