A Map That Could Have Predicted El Niño ✎

Original: "Long-term non-linear predictability of ENSO events over the 20th century"
arXiv:1506.04066 · 2015-06-12 · arXiv non-exclusive · independent analysis · 3 min
The Southern Oscillation Index holds enough information to forecast El Niño events two to four years ahead.

In 1997, the Pacific Ocean off the coast of Peru warmed so much that fish disappeared and torrential rains hit the desert. This is El Niño, a warm current that every few years changes weather across the planet. Predicting its arrival six months ahead is already possible, but looking further is like guessing a ship's route from a single point on a map.

However, the climate system has its own map: the attractor. This is the shape traced by the system's trajectory in state space when the axes are not time but the variables themselves: pressure, temperature, wind speed. For El Niño, that map is the Southern Oscillation Index (SOI), the pressure difference between Tahiti and Darwin, recorded monthly since 1866. Each El Niño event leaves its own loop on this map, much like a ship's wake.

An attractor is not a place but a shape. If a system repeats its states, its trajectory in state space winds into the same loops, like a carousel that always returns to the same point.

The scientists decomposed 135 years of records into nine layers, from fast intraseasonal oscillations to a slow trend, and built a nine-dimensional space. Then, for the 1997–1998 event, they took its starting point and searched the past for similar points. Three were found: 1911, 1972–1973, and 1982–1983. Shifting their trajectories to the event's start and averaging them yields a forecast. The error two years ahead was less than half the standard deviation of the entire signal, and four years ahead no more than 0.37. This means that the map of the past could have revealed the outlines of the future in advance.

But the map does not always work. For the 1982–1983 event, no suitable loop was found in the past, leaving the forecast inaccurate. Perhaps this is a rare state of the attractor that has not repeated in 135 years of observations. Nevertheless, for most events of the 20th century, the method gives an average forecast two to four years ahead, and this is shown for the first time for the extreme El Niño of 1997–1998, which was usually poorly predicted.

The spring predictability barrier is the loss of forecast accuracy in spring. This work shows that the barrier can be bypassed by looking not at statistical correlations but at the geometry of the attractor.

Previously, it was thought that looking beyond six months was nearly impossible because of too much noise in the data. Now it is clear that the SOI index itself encodes nonlinear information sufficient for forecasts years ahead. The method requires no complex models, only wavelet decomposition and a search for similar orbits. It can be applied to other climate records to test whether predictability persists beyond the 20th century. The map of the past, if you learn to read it, shows the road to the future.

The 1997–1998 El Niño was so strong that it is called the 'climate event of the century': it caused droughts in Indonesia and Australia, floods in Peru and California, and is estimated to have led to the deaths of more than 20,000 people.

In Kim Stanley Robinson's novel 'Forty Signs of Rain', climatologists try to predict abrupt changes in ocean currents, and in the film 'The Day After Tomorrow', a sudden climate shift begins with anomalies in the Pacific Ocean. The theme of long-term forecasting of such events remains fantastically difficult.

Concepts
Southern Oscillation index Multivariate ENSO Index El Niño-Southern Oscillation spring predictability barrier ENSO Teleconnection Jin-Timmermann model equatorial wave propagation recharge oscillator model relative ONI ERSST NOAA CPC TAO/TRITON moorings Niño 4 NOAA PMEL / TAO seasonal cycle natural variability seasonal forcing La Niña interannual variability