How to Hear the Pauses in the Ocean–Land Conversation

Original: "Lagged teleconnections of climate variables identified via complex rotated Maximum Covariance Analysis"
arXiv:2105.04618 · 2021-05-10 · CC BY 4.0 · 2 min
Scientists have found a way to detect that rainfall in one place responds to ocean heat only after several months.

In 1960, a meteorologist at a station in Peru records water temperature, while a farmer in India watches the sky for the monsoon. There is no direct link between these two events, but months later one will echo in the other. Earth's climate is like a conversation where the speakers reply not immediately but after a pause: the ocean warms, and only months later does the rainfall pattern change on another continent. Old methods could only hear simultaneous remarks, so half the conversation remained unintelligible.

The new method turns each observational series into a special signal that shifts oscillations by a quarter period. This makes it possible to notice that the maximum heat in one region occurs earlier than the peak of rainfall in another.

The scientists took data on sea surface temperature and land precipitation from 1960 to 2019, smoothed them, and turned them into complex signals. Then they found common patterns and rotated them so that each pattern became clear and interpretable. The result was six main modes: the seasonal cycle (which explains 62.7% of the total relationship), El Niño, global warming, the Pacific Decadal Oscillation, El Niño Modoki, and the Atlantic Meridional Mode. For example, the seasonal temperature maximum in the northern Pacific occurs 196 days later than in the southern Pacific, and in the Indian Ocean, rains lag the heat by 81 days.

Now the ocean–land conversation can be heard in full, with all its pauses. Previously, each such connection was sought separately, with a prior assumption about which delay mattered. The new method does everything in one procedure and does not require detrending, which is important in a changing climate. The farmer in India and the meteorologist in Peru are linked by an invisible thread of delayed signal, and we are now learning to discern it amid the noise.

The seasonal temperature maximum in the northern Pacific occurs 196 days later than in the southern Pacific, which is almost exactly half a year. This means the two ocean hemispheres work in antiphase, like a seesaw with a very slow period.

The idea of delayed teleconnections recalls the 'butterfly effect' from Ray Bradbury's story 'A Sound of Thunder': a small event in one place, through a chain of connections, leads to major consequences elsewhere. Only here the connections are not chaotic but statistically stable.

\hat{X}_s = X_s + i H(X_s)
Each time series is turned into a complex one, where the imaginary part is phase-shifted by a quarter period
A_s = (V_s \odot \bar{V}_s)^{\odot 1/2}
Shows in which regions a given mode is most pronounced
\Theta_s = \arctan2(\mathrm{Im}(V_s), \mathrm{Re}(V_s))
Gives the relative temporal shift at each point; for narrowband signals it translates into a delay
Concepts
Teleconnection reanalysis Atlantic multidecadal oscillation multifractal detrended fluctuation analysis ocean-atmosphere coupling decadal variability ERA5 climate network North Atlantic Oscillation climate marine heatwave covariance matrix coupled general circulation model seasonal forcing seasonal cycle empirical orthogonal function mixed mode oscillations GODAS natural variability principal component analysis