Southern Hemisphere: Ice, Sun, and El Niño ✎

Original: "On the Warming of the Southern Hemisphere since 1955 and Recent Slowing-Down: Role of Sea Ice, Sun Spot and El Nino Variability"
· Alfred Laubereau, Hristo Iglev
arXiv:1807.05676 · 2018-07-16 · arXiv non-exclusive · independent analysis · 3 min
Antarctic sea ice contributed twice as much to Southern Hemisphere warming as greenhouse gases.

Context

This work sits on the fringe: almost nothing else is nearby, with the nearest neighbor at a distance of 0.532. Surrounding studies link climate to space weather, solar activity, and the long memory of ice sheets. This paper is not about distant cycles but about a concrete mechanism: how the retreat of sea ice off Antarctica alters the heat balance of an entire hemisphere.

Methods

The authors used a one-dimensional four-layer atmospheric model. The surface is treated as a blackbody emitter, and each layer as a selective thermal emitter with parameters taken from greenhouse gas spectroscopy. Layer and surface temperatures are determined from thermal equilibrium without any tuning parameters. Albedo changes were estimated from historical sea ice extent data: from 1955 to 1979 they used proxies and assimilation, and from 1979 onward, satellite observations. Additionally, a relaxation time τ was introduced to account for the delayed temperature response to ice changes.

Results

The direct contribution of greenhouse gases to Southern Hemisphere warming over 1955–2015 was 0.2 ± 0.05 K. The albedo feedback from melting Antarctic sea ice contributed 0.5 ± 0.1 K. The sum matches the observed temperature rise of 0.75 ± 0.1 K. A model with a relaxation time of 30 years best fits the data. Extrapolation to 2015–2025 predicts a 33% slowdown in warming compared to 2005–2015. Correlations were also found between annual temperature fluctuations and solar activity and the El Niño index.

Implications

This work stands out from its neighbors by providing a quantitative estimate of sea ice's contribution to hemispheric warming, rather than discussing qualitative mechanisms. It is the first test of the hypothesis that ice albedo plays a dominant role in the Southern Hemisphere using historical data. The result challenges models that attribute most warming to greenhouse gases without accounting for the ocean's slow relaxation.

Future development

The topic could evolve toward more detailed accounting of regional differences: ice is growing in the Ross Sea and melting in the Bellingshausen Sea, while the one-dimensional model averages these processes. Including a two-dimensional distribution of solar flux by latitude is possible, which has so far yielded only a few percent correction but could become important when refining the relaxation time. It would also be interesting to test the predicted slowdown against post-2015 data.

Impact

The results will affect climate models that need to correctly account for the sea ice albedo feedback. They are also important for interpreting satellite observations of Antarctic ice.

Next steps

The next step is to compare the model's prediction with actual Southern Hemisphere temperature data for 2015–2025. It is also worth refining historical ice extent estimates before 1979 using whaling records and other proxies.

Key open problems

This work addresses an unresolved problem in climatology: why Antarctic sea ice grew from 1979 despite global warming. The authors show that the ocean's long memory may explain this paradox, but a full understanding of regional processes is still lacking.

From 1955 to 1979, Antarctic sea ice extent shrank by 23% in winter and 67% in summer, then partially recovered. This is like a spring slowly uncoiling in the climate system.

\tau \frac{d(\Delta albedo)}{dt} = -\Delta albedo + G_{rel}(t)
The hemispheric albedo change lags behind the Antarctic albedo change with a characteristic time τ.
\sum_{i=0}^{4} \eta_{ij} T_i^4 = f_j \eta_{jj} T_j^4 - \frac{B_j - B_{j+1}}{\sigma}
For each layer j, the total radiative flux from all layers and the surface equals the flux emitted by the layer plus non-radiative heat transport.

Key numbers

  • Ice contribution to warming: 0.5 ± 0.1 K
  • Greenhouse gas contribution: 0.2 ± 0.05 K
  • Total warming 1955–2015: 0.75 ± 0.1 K
  • Predicted slowdown 2015–2025: 33%
  • Relaxation time: 30 years
Concepts
El Niño La Niña ENSO El Niño-Southern Oscillation relative ONI global warming Bjerknes feedback ERSST UAH satellite record Earth's energy imbalance Warm water volume greenhouse effect sea surface temperature anomaly seasonal cycle NOAA CPC sea surface temperature seasonal forcing Southern Oscillation Multivariate ENSO Index Ocean heat content