Black Holes Spin Independently of Their Galaxies ✛ ✎ ✦

Original: "The direction of rotation of supermassive black holes is unrelated to the direction of rotation of the host galaxy"
· Loren Gigi, C. Martin Gaskell
arXiv:2607.06902 · 2026-07-08 · arXiv non-exclusive · independent analysis · 1 min
Supermassive black holes at the centers of galaxies spin in any direction, not matching the rotation of the galaxy itself.

It was once thought that the supermassive black hole at a galaxy's center spins in the same direction as the galaxy itself — like a whirlpool in a sink. But measurements using polarized light analysis (a method that turns dust reflection into a spin arrow) showed the opposite. Out of 54 galaxies with active nuclei, 27 black holes spin clockwise, 27 counterclockwise. Among those where comparison with the galaxy was possible, 11 matched and 13 did not.

The picture is like a children's carousel with a spinning top in the center: the whole carousel rotates, but the top lives by its own rules — you can spin it in any direction. So it is with a black hole: its axis is set by the last major gas infall or collision with another hole, not by the multi-billion-year legacy of the parent galaxy.

Light reflected by dust near the hole's horizon acts as a cosmic mirror — its blue and red shifts reveal where the matter is flying.

This means that the hole grows its mass chaotically, contrary to old models of orderly feeding from a rotating galactic disk. An astonishing conclusion: many supermassive holes are probably not 'native inhabitants' of their galaxies, but interlopers captured in mergers. That's why narrow jets of radiation (radio jets) often shoot at an angle to the galactic pancake's plane — the hole is simply looking the other way. Now, to more accurately reproduce the growth of structures in the Universe, computer simulations must account for this cosmic messiness.

Polarized light method allows us to discern gas rotation at the black hole's edge, even when looking straight at it: dust acts as billions of tiny mirrors reflecting the motion.

In 'Interstellar,' the spin of the black hole Gargantua determines the flow of time. But real holes could spin perpendicular to their galaxy, adding even more weirdness.

a = \frac{Jc}{GM^2}
The dimensionless spin a describes how fast a black hole rotates: it can range from -1 to 1. It was its orientation, not just its magnitude, that became the bone of contention — like a spinning top, not only how fast but which way it spins matters.
\Delta PA \approx \frac{1}{2}\frac{v}{c} \sin i
The shift in polarization position angle is proportional to the gas velocity and orbital inclination, allowing the S-shaped line profile to reveal which way the accretion disk spins — like reading the wind direction from a flag's flutter.
Scientists
John Archibald WheelerJacob BekensteinStephen HawkingFritz ZwickyKarl SchwarzschildSubrahmanyan Chandrasekhar
Concepts
galactic plane black hole accretion winds host galaxy changing agn activity galaxy rotation black hole spin obscured agn horizon area hawking radiation anomalies viewing angle inclination orbit apparent horizon blazar stellar rotation milky way halo structure stellar planetary misalignment galactic center spin rate photon sphere