The Universe Remains Homogeneous: New Data ✛ ✎

Original: "The local galaxy distribution does not violate the cosmological principle"
· Till Sawala
arXiv:2607.01172v1 · 2026-07-01 · arXiv non-exclusive · independent analysis · 1 min
Recent claims of giant inhomogeneities in the Universe turned out to be the result of a distance calculation error.

Imagine a funhouse mirror that stretches everything vertically: a chair looks huge, though in reality it's just an ordinary one. That's somewhat similar to how astronomers sometimes see distorted images of distant space. Recent debates flared up precisely over the distribution of galaxies in the Universe.

Back in the day, Edwin Hubble and Georges Lemaître established that on very large scales, the cosmos is homogeneous and has no preferred directions. But in the spectroscopic survey DESI — which measures the redshift of distant objects — someone glimpsed a giant wall of galaxies billions of light-years long. Such a find would have called the foundations of cosmology into question.

In reality, the mysterious wall is the long-familiar Sloan Great Wall — its outlines just 'bloated' due to the error.

A new investigation compared real data with a computer simulation of the Universe called FLAMINGO, which accounts for dark matter and dark energy. It turned out that when you convert redshift into distance correctly, the observed picture fits perfectly with predictions based on the Big Bang. The whole drama arose from a mix-up: the authors of the sensation used one type of cosmic 'ruler' instead of another, causing distances to stretch by about one and a half times — as if you measured your waist with a tailor's tape but read the markings as inches instead of centimeters. Once the mistake was corrected, the monster illusion vanished, and the standard picture of the world, confirmed by the Hubble telescope, remained unshaken.

Due to the distance mix-up, the famous Sloan Great Wall briefly turned into a 'monster' billions of light-years long, though in reality it's much more modest.

Science fiction writers have often depicted worlds with anomalously large cosmic structures — for example, Ivan Yefremov's 'The Andromeda Nebula'.

\chi = \frac{d_L}{1+z}
Conversion from luminosity distance d_L to comoving distance χ via the (1+z) factor; ignoring this divisor stretches the scale by a factor of 1.5–1.8 at DESI redshifts.
Scientists
Alan GuthAlexander FriedmannAndrei LindeGeorges LemaîtreJames PeeblesAdam Riess
Concepts
cosmological homogeneity standard cosmological model cosmology galaxy distribution Cosmic Censorship Principle cosmic inflation non singular cosmology holographic principle andromeda galaxy standard ruler Hubble's law three dimensional map galactic circumgalactic medium false vacuum spatial curvature bubble hubble flow galactic plane holographic dark energy catalog