Why Technetium and Promethium Are Outcasts of the Periodic Table ✎ express

Original: "Nuclear mass staggering explains missing stable technetium and promethium"
arXiv:2607.29081v1 · 2026-07-31 · arXiv non-exclusive · independent analysis · 2 min
Two elements lack stable isotopes due to a special interaction between protons and neutrons in the nucleus.

📄 Showing the "Simple" version — "Popular" is not ready yet. Add it to favorites to help prioritize it.

In nuclear physics, a puzzle has long been nagging: why among elements lighter than bismuth, only technetium (No. 43) and promethium (No. 61) have no stable isotope at all? All their neighbors in the periodic table can boast at least one long-lived variant, but these two seem to fall out of the general pattern. A group of researchers approached the problem as a search for 'gaps' in the sequence of the lightest odd-mass nuclei. They decomposed the masses of isobars (nuclei with the same number of particles but different charges) into two components: a smooth parabola and sharp jumps between odd protons and odd neutrons.

The smooth part is well described by standard nuclear models that account for shell structure. But the jumps are the key to the solution. In the region of technetium and promethium, they turned out to be positive and large enough. As a result, the sequence of the lightest isobars seems to 'skip over' them.

Tensor forces in the nucleus act like a selective magnet: they attract protons and neutrons more strongly when their spins are parallel, and more weakly when they are antiparallel. It is this asymmetry that creates the energy shift that 'ejects' technetium and promethium from the stable ones.

Analysis of nuclear shell filling showed that the observed stepwise change in masses is associated with a special type of interaction — the tensor effect in the proton-neutron pair. This effect depends on the mutual orientation of the spins (intrinsic angular momenta) of the particles and the shape of their orbits. In the end, nature seems to say: 'Here, at numbers 43 and 61, stability has no place.' Thus, tensor forces, usually unnoticeable against the background of other nuclear interactions, have manifested themselves in pure form.

Technetium became the first artificially produced element: it was synthesized in 1937, and its name comes from the Greek 'technetos' (artificial).

In Stanislaw Lem's novel 'Fiasco', technetium is mentioned as a rare element used in technologies of the far future.

Scientists
Emmy NoetherWolfgang PauliEnrico FermiPaul DiracChien-Shiung WuEugene Wigner
Concepts
nuclear stability critical mass neutron mass strange quark nuclear shell positronium magic number crust deuterium nucleon atomic nucleus lithium titanium neutron tantalum pair instability supernova charm quark deuteron z boson atom