Thorium-229: How to Hear a Nucleus in an Opaque Crystal ✛

Original: "$$^{229}$$Th Nuclear Spectroscopy in an Opaque Material: Laser-Based Conversion Electron Mössbauer Spectroscopy of $$^{229}$$ThO$$_2$$"
arXiv:2506.03018v1 · 2025-06-03 · CC BY 4.0 · 3 min
A laser excites the thorium-229 nucleus in a ThO2 film, and a detector catches electrons that fly out instead of light.

A thin film of thorium dioxide, just 10 nanometers thick, is deposited on a steel disk. A laser pulse strikes it, but instead of the expected glow, the detector catches a stream of electrons. This is how, for the first time, the nuclear transition of thorium-229 was observed in a material that completely absorbs its own radiation. The invisible nucleus spoke the language of electrons.

The nuclear transition in thorium-229 is the lowest-energy known: just 8.4 eV. That's the energy of an ultraviolet photon, not a gamma ray. So the nucleus can be excited with a laser, not an accelerator.

The transition in thorium-229 is unique: its energy is so low that the nucleus can be driven by an ordinary laser tuned to a wavelength of about 148 nanometers. But until now, such experiments were only possible in crystals transparent to vacuum ultraviolet light, such as calcium fluoride or thorium fluoride. Transparency was a prerequisite: otherwise, the photon emitted by the nucleus would not escape and could not be detected. This limited the choice of materials and prevented the study of many thorium compounds, such as its oxide ThO2.

The new approach uses a different decay channel of the excited nucleus: internal conversion. Instead of transferring energy to a photon, the nucleus transfers it to one of its own atomic electrons, kicking it out of the shell. The electron escapes the material and can be captured by a detector. This makes the nuclear transition audible even in an opaque medium. The experiment used a microchannel plate that collected electrons using electric and magnetic fields. To filter out background photoelectrons, the target was alternately charged positive and negative, and the detector was switched on with a delay after the laser pulse. By scanning the laser frequency, a resonant peak was observed at 2020407.5 GHz, consistent with measurements in transparent crystals.

The lifetime of the excited nucleus under internal conversion in ThO2 turned out to be about 12 microseconds, millions of times shorter than in an isolated nucleus. This paves the way for nuclear clocks with fast readout.

The measured lifetime of the isomeric state, 12.3 microseconds, is an order of magnitude shorter than the theoretical estimate for a bulk crystal. The discrepancy is attributed to defects and surface effects. But even this lifetime allows estimating the potential instability of nuclear clocks based on ThO2: about 2×10⁻¹⁸ per second of averaging. This is on par with the best atomic clocks, but in a device that could fit on a chip.

The method of conversion electron spectroscopy lifts a fundamental limitation: now, not only transparent crystals but also oxides, nitrides, and other compounds with narrow bandgaps are suitable for thorium nuclear spectroscopy. This opens the possibility of studying how the local environment of the nucleus, including phonons, electronic structure, and defects, affects the transition frequency and conversion rate. In the long run, it could lead to nuclear clocks with electrical readout: conversion electrons create a current that can be measured directly, without bulky optics.

The thin film on a steel disk becomes a sensor capable of picking up the signal of an invisible beacon: the nuclear transition. A beacon that could previously only be seen in a transparent medium can now be heard in the dark.

The energy of the nuclear transition in thorium-229 is only 8.4 eV, roughly the energy of an ultraviolet photon, which is orders of magnitude lower than typical nuclear energies (MeV). This allows the nucleus to be excited with a laser rather than an accelerator.

The idea of ultra-precise clocks based on a nuclear transition echoes the concept of "atomic clocks" in science fiction, such as in Frank Herbert's "Dune," where precise timekeeping plays a key role in navigation. In reality, nuclear clocks could surpass atomic clocks in stability and compactness.

\Delta f/f \approx 2\times 10^{-18}
The projected relative frequency instability of a ThO2-based nuclear clock over a 1-second averaging time is two orders of magnitude better than cesium standards.
Concepts
thorium 229 nuclear optical clock laser spectroscopy proton spectroscopy laser cooling Mössbauer effect optoelectronic device optical clock boron optoelectronics lead nucleus ytterbium atomic transition electron microscopy electron capture radioactive decay tantalum ionized gas charge transfer states