Cosmic Top: How a Wobbling Jet Explained the GW170817 Mystery express

Original: "The Very Late Time Afterglow of GW170817 Favors a Wobbling Jet"
arXiv:2605.13719 · 2026-05-13 · CC BY 4.0 · 1 min
The collision of neutron stars produced not a narrow beam but a swaying ring that has been illuminating cosmic dust for years.

In 2017, detectors picked up a tremor in space — gravitational waves from the merger of two neutron stars. At the same moment, telescopes saw a flash. For the first time, one event spoke in two languages at once: light and gravity. But the longer astronomers watched the fading glow, the stranger its behavior became.

Usually, such a collision produces a narrow jet — a beam of particles traveling at nearly the speed of light. If the jet is pointed away from us, its light should fade quickly as it expands. Here, things were different: the brightness declined very gradually. As if something kept illuminating the expanding cloud from within. This didn't fit the picture of a straight beam.

The authors of the study proposed that the jet wasn't stationary. It wobbled, like a garden hose under high pressure, tracing a glowing ring across the sky. Over time, we see a longer arc of this ring — which is why the light fades so slowly. Computer simulations showed that such a 'wobbling' jet explains the observations 4.8 times better than a rigid narrow beam.

The wobble angle was about 27 degrees — a very strong tilt by cosmic standards. It suggests that the disk of material feeding the jet was heavily skewed, possibly due to gas falling in from an unexpected direction.

This isn't just solving one event. Slow fading has been seen in other gamma-ray bursts as well. If wobbling jets are common, our understanding of the most powerful explosions in the Universe is about to become much more dynamic.

If such a wobbling jet shone in visible light, a distant observer would see not a point but a gradually brightening and dimming ring, a cosmic 'donut' the size of the full Moon.

In Arthur C. Clarke's novel '2010: Odyssey Two', a mysterious ring on a moon of Jupiter turns out to be a gateway to other worlds — here, the ring is drawn by the physics of the explosion itself.

Scientists
Bernhard RiemannJoseph WeberKarl SchwarzschildKip ThorneRainer WeissAlbert Einstein
Concepts
gw170817 afterglow gw190814 stellar wobble event gamma ray burst merger wobble inspiral central engine supernova jets swift satellite magnetar pulsations in grb black hole recoil neutron star binary formation neutron star merger jet magnetic signature gravitational wave echoes gravitational wave resonance brown dwarf desert jet