theorem

Witten's positive energy theorem

The positive energy theorem states that the total ADM mass of an asymptotically flat spacetime is non-negative and zero only for Minkowski space.
42 related articles · 1 who worked here

Description

4×10^24 kilograms is the mass of Earth. The positive energy theorem answers the question of whether the gravitational field can add a negative contribution. In 1979, Richard Schoen and Shing-Tung Yau proved that it cannot: the total energy of an isolated system in general relativity is always non-negative. Edward Witten provided an elegant spinor proof in 1981. Nature is a meticulous bookkeeper, allowing no deficits.

History

The question of energy positivity in GR goes back to Einstein's work, but a rigorous proof long eluded researchers. In 1959, Dirac conjectured it, and in 1962, Arnowitt, Deser, and Misner introduced the ADM mass. In 1979, mathematicians Richard Schoen and Shing-Tung Yau proved the theorem for dimensions ≤7. In 1981, Edward Witten found a simple proof for spin manifolds of any dimension, based on supergravity. His approach became classical.

How it works

It is used to prove the stability of Minkowski space as the ground state. In numerical simulations of black hole mergers, it guarantees that the mass of radiation will not exceed the initial sum. Limitation: works only for asymptotically flat spaces and when energy conditions are satisfied (e.g., for classical matter).

In practice

Guarantees the stability of black holes and stars: they cannot collapse into 'nothing' with negative energy. When calculating satellite orbits in strong fields, the theorem rules out options with a 'negative gravitational charge'.

Fun fact

Witten used spinors—mathematical objects resembling 'square roots' of vectors. His proof is so compact that it fits into a couple of pages.

Concept graph →

Related articles · 48

Magnetic Resonance Without a Microscope: A New Theory for Living Tissue
A sculptor looks at a block of marble and sees the figure within, waiting to be freed from excess material. Instead of adding clay, he removes everything that is not part of the form. The authors of a new study on magnetic resonance took a similar approach: rather than complicating the tissue model by adding ever more details, they stripped away the superfluous to reveal the essence.
General Relativity2026-08-072 minarXiv:2608.06852express
The Universe Couldn't Have Been Expanding Forever
A spotlight beam fades into the darkness, but if you trace it backward, you hit the lamp. The history of the universe might be the same: tracing its expansion backward, we run into a beginning. Physicists took the simplest model — a universe that stretches equally in all directions, like a cube with all sides growing.
Cosmology2026-08-052 minarXiv:2608.04763express
Dark Matter Isn't Quite the Invisible Wallflower
The cosmological standard model is like a recipe for a cake where everything is strictly measured: dark matter is like flour without a single lump (zero pressure), and dark energy is like the perfect leavening agent (equation of state exactly minus one). But what if the flour is a bit damp and the leavening agent has lost its oomph?
HEP Theory2026-08-042 minarXiv:2608.04107express
Machine Learning Peers into the Heart of a Black Hole
A black hole is like a perfect safe: everything that falls in disappears without a trace. But quantum mechanics whispers that on the microscopic level, information is not lost but recorded on an invisible "surface." Understanding this record means unraveling the fabric of gravity.
General Relativity2026-08-032 minarXiv:2608.01814express
How Energy Learns to Behave Itself
In the big world, there's a simple rule: energy density can't be negative, and its flow can't outrun light. In a café, that would look like this: a waiter can't deliver orders faster than he can run. Physicists call this restriction the energy dominance condition. But in the microworld, where quanta rule and spacetime can bend, energy starts acting up.
Gravitational building codes: what force ceiling does Einstein's theory prescribe
An engineering blueprint of a skyscraper always includes a number: the maximum load on the foundation — say, 500 kilopascals. Einstein's field equations in curved spacetime impose a similar limit on the 'force load' inside stars, planets, and any other clumps of matter.
General Relativity2026-07-112 minarXiv:2607.10213express
Magnetic Fields Warp Empty Space
An inflatable balloon with magnetic field lines drawn on it with a marker is a simple model of how a weak magnetic field behaves in an expanding universe. While the balloon is small, the lines lie obediently on the rubber and don't hinder its stretching. That's roughly how a field fills ready-made space without arguing with its geometry.
HEP Theory2026-07-082 minarXiv:2607.07295express
Dark Matter from Five Dimensions
The world around us is three-dimensional, but perhaps that's just an illusion. Some theories allow for extra dimensions of space, curled up or stretched in special ways. One such model depicts a five-dimensional universe with a "diluted" dimension (called a linear dilaton).
Cosmology2026-07-072 minarXiv:2607.06735
Behind the Dark Matter Curtain: How Dark Energy Flipped Its Sign
The universe is a grand orchestra, with dark energy conducting the expansion. Ten billion years ago, the conductor changed its gesture: the negative pressure that had been holding back galaxy assembly gave way to accelerating expansion — the very phenomenon discovered by [scientist:Saul…
General Relativity2026-07-051 minarXiv:2607.04291express
A Star with Negative Mass
In the ordinary world without dark energy, the mass of any object is always positive. That seems obvious: positive mass attracts, creating gravity. But the real universe has dark energy — a mysterious force making the cosmos expand faster and faster.
math.NT2026-07-014 minarXiv:2607.00282
Every Ninth Zero: A Mathematical Sieve on the River of Primes
In the infinite river of integers, where whirlpools of primes swirl, mathematicians have been sifting sand for centuries in search of golden nuggets — the zeros of L‑functions. These enigmatic objects, discovered by Riemann in 1859, act like an invisible hand governing the distribution of primes.
Dark Energy: Inevitability Born of Symmetry
The explosion of a distant supernova told us something hard to believe: the universe is expanding faster and faster. The engine of this acceleration is dark energy — nearly 70% of everything that exists.
HEP Theory2026-06-241 minarXiv:2606.25326express
Charging from Nothing
The void is never truly empty. In curved spacetime (for instance, in an expanding universe or near a black hole) the vacuum heats up. This is reminiscent of how acceleration makes particles appear seemingly out of nowhere: a phenomenon known as thermal vacuum radiation.
General Relativity2026-06-212 minarXiv:2606.22404express
A Black Hole Turns White: What Has to Break
Light passing near a massive body slightly changes its path — gravity pulls even on rays. In ordinary situations, a beam of light from a distant star is squeezed as if drawn together by an invisible rubber band. This property is called the null convergence condition: gravity makes light trajectories converge rather than diverge.
General Relativity2026-06-212 minarXiv:2606.22531express
Warp drive without exotic matter: a maneuver that costs half the ship
At the heart of a warp drive lies Einstein's idea that massive bodies curve spacetime — the very stage on which all cosmic events unfold. Picture a bubble of such curved spacetime. Inside it, the ship floats without any G-forces, like a passenger in an airplane cabin who doesn't feel the headwind.
HEP Theory2026-06-142 minarXiv:2606.16024express
Vacuum cracks not with a bubble but with a pair of rings
An empty glass on the table seems reliable. But if there's a microcrack in the bottom, one day it will break — not with a crash, but quietly, spreading in a web of lines. So too with the vacuum: it may not be the true vacuum but a false one — temporarily stable, yet ready to transition to a deeper, real state.
General Relativity2026-06-121 minarXiv:2606.14076express
Black Hole Without Einstein's Equations
A black hole is not just a dark spot in space. It is a region where gravity compresses matter so intensely that even light cannot escape. Among all possible black holes, one stands out — the rotating Kerr black hole. Its description was long thought to be tied to Einstein's equations, like a recipe tied to a specific cookbook.
General Relativity2026-06-091 minarXiv:2606.11062express
Dark Energy: From Brake to Engine
The universe is expanding faster and faster thanks to dark energy. But measurements of the rate give contradictory results. A new explanation: in the past, dark energy acted as a brake, slowing the galaxies' recession, and then switched to acceleration. Like a car that first rolls backward and then lunges forward.
General Relativity2026-06-081 minarXiv:2606.09786express
Spin Inside a Neutron Star: How a Vortex of Matter Rewrites the Rules
A neutron star is the leftover core of an exploded giant, compressed to the size of a city. A teaspoon of its matter weighs a billion tons. Inside such a star, particles are packed so tightly that quantum effects start to show. One of them is the intrinsic rotation of particles, or spin.
Quantum Physics2026-06-071 minarXiv:2606.08595express
Time Flows Through Quantum Clocks
Time in physics is like a conductor setting the tempo for the whole orchestra. But in the quantum world, there's no single baton: each particle can live by its own clock. Usually, we simplify the picture and assume time flows the same for everyone.
General Relativity2026-06-062 minarXiv:2606.08022express
Wormholes Without Exotic Matter
Usually, a wormhole is imagined as a tunnel in space, whose walls are held open by something unusual — matter with negative energy. Like the supports in a mine that keep the ceiling from collapsing. But in this work, the physicists did without supports.
General Relativity2026-06-061 minarXiv:2606.08182express
A Tiny Black Hole Cools to Absolute Zero
An ordinary black hole is like a stove that heats up more as its mass shrinks. A tiny hole should glow at unimaginable temperatures and evaporate in an instant. But that scenario ignores quantum corrections — what happens when the very fabric of spacetime begins to tremble.
General Relativity2026-06-051 minarXiv:2606.07781express
How to Weigh a Black Hole from the Inside
A black hole is like a bottomless well. You can measure how much water has flowed into it by watching the level from outside. But how do you find the mass of the water itself if you're standing inside the well? That's roughly the problem the authors of a new paper tackle.
HEP Theory2026-05-312 minarXiv:2606.01103express
Dark Matter as a Drop of Quantum Liquid
A lump of dark matter drifts through the void — invisible, almost intangible. No one knows what it's made of, but a new study suggests viewing it as a drop of quantum liquid. Two kinds of fermion particles — call them "heavy" (ψ) and "light" (χ)—exchange signals via a third mediator particle (φ), like floats tied to a single line.
General Relativity2026-05-292 minarXiv:2605.31585express
How Waves and Shock Fronts Come Alive in Einstein's Equations
A taut sheet wrinkles. If you tug a corner, a smooth wave runs across; if you sharply bunch the fabric, a sharp crease forms. Space and time in Einstein's equations behave much the same way. Gravitational waves resemble the gentle ripples of the sheet, while shock fronts are like stiff folds where matter's properties change abruptly.
General Relativity2026-05-182 minarXiv:2605.18965express
A Universe Without an Edge: Why an Open World Cannot Be Eternal
A heavy ball rests on a trampoline, and the fabric sags beneath it. Any rolling ball nearby inevitably rolls toward the center. This is roughly how gravity works on the scale of the entire Universe. But what if the fabric were arched upward, like a dome? Then the ball would tend to roll outward.
HEP Phenomenology2026-05-152 minarXiv:2605.16201express
The Gravitational Whisper of the Universe's Birth
Imagine a giant orchestra where every musician is a particle born in the fire of the Big Bang. When time's baton gives the downbeat, these particles begin to decay into lighter ones. Each decay is accompanied by a quiet chord — the emission of gravitons, tiny quanta of gravity.
The Angular Momentum Symphony: When Weak Gravity Is Strong
Back in the 1930s, Fritz Zwicky noticed that the speeds of galaxies in clusters were too high for the visible mass. Later, Vera Rubin confirmed this for individual galaxies.
Geometry's Verdict: Why Wormholes Are Doomed to Exoticity
Since time immemorial, physicists have dreamed of tunnels piercing the cosmos — wormholes, capable of connecting far-flung corners of the Universe in an instant.
General Relativity2026-05-101 minarXiv:2605.09660express
The Universe Checks Its Own Honesty
When two dead stars collide in a distant galaxy, two messengers bring us the news: a shiver in space, a gravitational wave, and a flash of light. Both messengers race toward us across the entire Universe, but their paths can differ slightly. Light sometimes gets delayed by cosmic dust, while gravitational waves pass through everything almost without noticing obstacles.
HEP Theory2026-05-082 minarXiv:2605.08058express
Cosmic Doughnuts with a Gravity Filling
A mathematical doughnut, a torus, sits on the boundary of a three-dimensional world where gravity acts. You can crumple and stretch it, and physicists decided to see how it behaves. Inside this world, space can be flat like a table, expanding like a soap bubble, or curved like a saddle. The doughnut boundary refused to stay smooth.
The Singularity That Never Was: How Quantum Tango Erases the Beginning of the Universe
In physics, there's an old ache. General relativity paints the beginning of the universe as a point — a singularity where equations break down and volume shrinks to zero. Quantum mechanics hints that at the most critical moment, something goes differently than classical physics predicts.
General Relativity2026-05-031 minarXiv:2605.01992express
Friction in the Early Universe: Saving Inflation
The idea of inflation, the superfast expansion of space just after its birth, was proposed by Alan Guth in 1980. It explained why our world is so uniform. But fresh snapshots of the Big Bang from the ACT telescope showed a pattern that slightly didn't match the predictions of two leading models.
HEP Theory2026-04-241 minarXiv:2604.22418express
Gravitational Waves Without Distortion
In 2015, the LIGO detectors caught the first burst of gravitational waves — astronomers heard two black holes colliding far out in space. That ripple in spacetime reached us with its signal shape intact: like the sound of a bell traveling billions of years without distortion.
Quantum Ripples in Active Matter
A handful of rice grains falls onto a hot skillet, and they start jumping. Each grain pushes its neighbors, and the whole pile stirs without any external hand. That's active matter: a multitude of particles that draw energy on their own and convert it into motion.
HEP Theory2026-04-192 minarXiv:2604.17583express
How an Invisible Membrane Reshapes the Vacuum
The void is not as empty as it seems. In the quantum world, even in a perfect vacuum, pairs of particles constantly pop in and out of existence, like ripples on a pond's surface, invisible to the eye but measurable. If you place a thin partition in this ripple, it alters the wave pattern.
HEP Theory2026-04-192 minarXiv:2604.17649express
How Spacetime Emerges from Quantum Ripples
A drop of cream falls into a cup of coffee, and within a minute, the entire drink turns beige. This mixing process can be quantified: how much "stirring" is needed to transform one distribution of particles into another? In mathematics, this approach is called optimal transport, and the measure of effort is the Wasserstein distance. The authors applied this idea to quantum systems.
General Relativity2026-04-131 minarXiv:2604.11167express
Catcher of Invisible Forces
On the table sits a sensitive instrument — a torsion balance. Two heavy masses rotate near a suspended rod, and their attraction tends to twist the rod. But the masses are arranged so that their ordinary Newtonian attraction cancels out: one pulls one way, the other the opposite. Only a weak residual remains, which the instrument captures.
Strongly Correlated2026-03-241 minarXiv:2603.22736express
Phase Transition Without Symmetry Breaking
A crowd of people moves freely across a square, but suddenly freezes in place without changing their positions. Everyone stays where they were, but motion stops. This is exactly what a symmetric mass generation transition looks like: the system gains rigidity, yet its symmetry remains untouched.
General Relativity2026-03-151 minarXiv:2603.14159express