hubble tension

A drop of ink spreads in a glass of water: its edges move faster than its center, and the drop's shape changes. Likewise, a clump of dark matter collapsing under its own gravity expands unevenly, with different shells flying apart at different speeds. Previously, astrophysicists could accurately describe only the simplest case, a uniform sphere with a sharp boundary, which has a single expansion rate.

In the heart of an old city stands a clock tower whose hands have never been adjusted since it was built. By how far it runs slow, you can calculate how much time has stretched since then. In space, the role of such towers is played by relic galaxies — dense stellar systems that formed in the first few billion years and have since neither merged with neighbors nor given birth to new stars.

A lamp is hidden behind a large aquarium filled with water. You see not one light source but several reflections and refractions — the water bends the path of the rays.

Six runners sprint down the track, and officials time their speed without noticing a tailwind. The wind blows at their backs, and the stopwatches show a better result than the truth. Roughly this is how six megamasers — natural cosmic lasers in distant galaxies — misled astronomers measuring the expansion rate of the universe.

Measuring distances in the universe is no easy task. Almost all methods rely on light, which can be absorbed by dust, scattered, or distorted along the way. It's like trying to spot a distant lighthouse through fog and haze. Neutrinos are a different story. These ghostly particles pass through anything without noticing obstacles.

The cosmic dawn is hidden behind a dense veil of time. To see beyond it, you need to catch the radio signal from clouds of neutral hydrogen — the so-called global 21 cm signal. But it is so faint that the receiver's own noise drowns it out.

The universe is a vast, dark ocean. We see only the glowing foam on its surface — stars and galaxies. But hidden in the depths are two invisible forces: dark matter, which with its gravity keeps galaxies from flying apart, and dark energy, which, on the contrary, pushes space itself apart, making the universe expand faster and faster.

In 1998, physicists caught neutrinos doing something astonishing: the particle changes its type on the fly. That is only possible if it has mass. This became the only laboratory proof of physics beyond the Standard Model. But exactly how much a neutrino weighs remains a mystery.

Cosmology has landed in an interesting pickle. The two main ways to look back into the universe's past, via the early glow (the cosmic microwave background) and via later objects like supernovae, yield different numbers for the expansion rate (the Hubble constant) and for how clumpy matter is distributed.

380 thousand years after the Big Bang, the universe cooled enough for light to decouple from plasma. That cosmic microwave background still pervades space, like the first chord of a symphony, the echo of a fiery beginning.

Two galaxies (our Milky Way and its satellite, the Large Magellanic Cloud) slowly circle each other. Their gravitational pull stirs the distant outskirts of the Milky Way, like a pebble thrown into a pond makes the water ripple.

Through three minutes after the Big Bang, the Universe played its first symphony. It was the big bang nucleosynthesis — the formation of light nuclei, where each element sounded its own note, and the tempo was set by the expansion of space.

A cold, black mirror — that's what the sea of dark energy, the invisible substance driving the expansion of the universe, looked like for billions of years. But the DESI spectrograph has caught a faint ripple.

The universe cooled like a giant bathtub after a hot start. At 400 000 years after the Big Bang, hydrogen was ready to recombine — protons capturing electrons to become neutral atoms. But somewhere in this dark water, a tap kept dripping.

Gravity isn't just the force that keeps us on the floor. On cosmic scales, it conducts galaxies, bends light rays, and decides the fate of everything. A century ago, Einstein described it as the curvature of space and time.

The cosmological debate is like two craftsmen measuring the same wall but getting different lengths. One uses a tape measure, applying it to nearby landmarks — Cepheids (pulsating beacon stars) and Type Ia supernovae (flashes of dying stars). He finds the wall is stretching at 73.5 arbitrary units.

A drama is brewing in cosmology: two principal musical instruments, the orchestra of the early Universe and the chamber ensemble of the modern cosmos, play the same symphony of expansion at different tempos.

Imagine a cosmic orchestra performing a symphony from the Big Bang to the present day. The conductor, dark energy, long seemed an impassive metronome: the cosmological constant Λ motionless, like a baton frozen in mid-air.

The Universe is an orchestra playing the symphony of the Big Bang. For a long time, the conductor was thought to be dark energy — an unwavering metronome setting the pace of expansion.

In a recent study, astrophysicists showed how pre-recombination physics, particularly early dark energy, affects the spectral running $$α_s$$ and, consequently, the viability of scenarios forming primordial black holes from an ultra-slow-roll (USR) phase during inflation.

Cosmology is like an orchestra where different sections suddenly start playing out of sync. Measurements of the universe's expansion rate (the Hubble constant) from the early and late universe give different numbers.

The cosmological orchestra doesn't tune to a single tuning fork. There are two groups of instruments: one listens to the hum of the young universe — the cosmic microwave background, while the other reads notes from mature galaxies and supernovae.

In the late 1990s, the night sky delivered a surprise: Saul Perlmutter and Adam Riess found that the expansion of the Universe is accelerating. Ever since, the greatest riddle has been dark energy — a substance making up nearly 70% of the cosmos, yet evading laboratory study.

The universe is a vast orchestra playing the score of expansion. Galaxies race apart to the beat of inaudible music of dark energy. But here's the trouble: the conductor's baton held by Edwin Hubble, Adam Riess, and Vera Rubin sets two incompatible tempos.

The Universe has a rate at which it expands — called the Hubble constant. The problem is that the two most precise ways to measure it give different numbers. One method, using the early light of the Universe (the cosmic microwave background), gives one value.

For decades, two independent methods of measuring the rate at which galaxies are flying apart, the Hubble constant, have given conflicting numbers. The situation resembled a room with two thermometers showing different temperatures.

A hum resonates across the universe. It is not sound, but a trembling of space itself — the gravitational wave background. It is produced by pairs of supermassive black holes circling each other at the centers of distant galaxies. Each pair is like a bass instrument in a vast orchestra.

Two rulers show slightly different lengths for the same table. That's roughly the situation in cosmology with the Hubble constant — the number that tells how fast the universe is expanding.

380,000 years after the Big Bang, the universe had cooled enough for scattered particles to combine into hydrogen atoms.

Cosmology is the music of the spheres, and the Hubble constant once seemed like a reliable metronome.

Cosmology resembles a courtroom where two witnesses give irreconcilable testimonies. The first — the analysis of the cosmic microwave background by the Planck satellite — claims: the expansion of the universe proceeds at 67 (km/s)/Mpc.

Cosmology is experiencing a tectonic rift. Cepheid-calibrated supernovae, measured by Adam Riess’s team, point to a rate of about 73 km/s per megaparsec.

Cosmologists staged a showdown between two kinds of cosmic explosions. Type Ia supernovae are stars that flare up with nearly identical brightness, making them reliable beacons for measuring distances across the universe.

A blacksmith forges a sword. With each hammer blow, the red-hot metal flattens, but the hammer, the anvil, and the surrounding air all warm up slightly. Part of the impact energy is irreversibly lost as heat — a trade-off familiar to anyone who has ever driven a nail, and it turns out to be the key to the biggest mysteries of the cosmos.

Imagine a giant inflatable balloon with galaxies painted on it. As it inflates, the pattern stretches and neighboring dots move apart. The rate of that stretching is the Hubble constant. Astronomers usually catch light from distant stars and see how much it has reddened due to the stretching of space.

On the kitchen counter, there's a flour scale and a measuring cup for water. Individually, they're precise, but when you bake bread, the recipe calls for the perfect ratio. Astronomers have a similar dispute about the universe's expansion rate.

The cosmic microwave background is the afterglow of the Big Bang, which we see at millimeter wavelengths. But it also has a long-wavelength tail extending into the radio range.

Imagine a huge layered cake, where the layers of dough are space and the filling is a special region resembling an invisible wall. This wall is not made of bricks but of energy, and it could be as thick as the entire universe. If such a wall exists, it should stretch the dough layers differently: those lying along it spread apart faster, while those across it spread slower.

Ancient light, traveling 14 billion years, reaches us from all directions. At first glance, it looks perfectly smooth, but if you look closely, tiny fluctuations appear, like ripples on a still pond. Those ripples aren't random noise; they're an encoded history of the universe.

An architect checks the blueprint when building a house. For cosmologists, the blueprint is the Standard Model, and the measuring tape is the light from distant galaxies. Recently, a new 'tape measure,' the DESI instrument, measured distances to millions of galaxies with unprecedented precision. And the numbers didn't match the blueprint.